This cemetery is confusing due to a separate cemetery with a related name. This cemetery is located on the northside of Princeton on North Hart and North Main Streets. The other cemetery which it is frequently confused with is the Maple Hill I.O.O.F. Cemetery on the southside of Princeton. It was purchased some time ago by a man who has since nearly abandoned the cemetery. As a result, this other cemetery is closed.
The sign on both I.O.O.F. cemeteries reads “Maple Hill IOOF cemeteries”. If you look at the photo on the Maple Hill IOOF cemetery, you will see that the owner had duplicate signs for both cemeteries made.
| Name | Unit | Image |
| Thomas Shipp | Company C, 63rd Indiana Infantry (The family stone shows his regiment as 63rd, but the government marker shows his regiment as 62nd, which is believed to be in error.) |
 |
| Francois Grigsby | Company F, 33rd Indiana Infantry |
 |
| John W. Angle | Company I, 17th Kentucky Infantry |
 |
| William Jones | Company H, 42nd Indiana Infantry |
 |
| Joseph Sherry | Company A, 80th Indiana Infantry |
 |
| Andrew McGregor | Company F, 42nd Indiana Infantry |
 |
| Samuel H. Shannon | Company K, 24th Indiana Infantry |
 |
| Josiah Pharr | Company A, 42nd Indiana Infantry |
 |
| John Leonard | Company B, 58th Indiana Infantry |
 |
| Hugh M. Clark | Company B, 58th Indiana Infantry |
 |
| Hugh M. Clark | Company B, 58th Indiana Infantry |
|
| Emil Weisgerber | Company F 33rd Indiana Infantry |
 |
| Samuel H. Sands | Company A & B, 24th Indiana Infantry |
 |
| Willis Coleman | Company D, 58th Indiana Infantry (Grandson of Hugh McGary) |
 |
| John Hyneman | Company E, 80th Indiana Infantry |
 |
| Henry M. Lamb | Company I, 1st Indiana Cavalry |
 |
| Joseph M. Skelton | Company G, 1st Indiana Cavalry |
 |
| Robert L. Gasaway | Company C, 136th Indiana Infantry |
 |
| John W. Turnage | Company K, 24th Indiana Infantry |
 |
| James J. Hartin | Company H, 17th Indiana Infantry |
 |
| Charles C. Whiting | Company A, 58th Indiana Infantry |
 |
| Benjamin F. Taylor | Company H, 20th Ohio Infantry |
 |
| James S. Mowery | Company F, 33rd Indiana Infantry |
 |
| John K. King | Company K, 80th Indiana Infantry |
 |
| Albert Mills | Company B, 58th Indiana Infantry |
 |
| William H. Spore | Company E, 80th Indiana Infantry |
 |
| William McDermott | Company F, 55th Pennsylvania Infantry |
 |
| John W. Bryant | Company F, 10th Pennsylvania Cavalry |
 |